Why Credit Score Myths Are So Persistent
Credit scores feel mysterious, so it’s easy for half-truths and myths to spread. Friends, family, and even some influencers may repeat outdated or flat-out wrong ideas.
If you’re just starting your money journey, these myths can:
- Make you **afraid to use credit at all**, or
- Push you into **using credit in harmful ways**
Let’s break down seven common credit score myths, explain what’s actually true, and give clear actions you can take.
---
Myth #1: “Checking Your Own Credit Score Will Hurt It”
This one scares a lot of beginners into flying blind.
The Truth
There are two main types of credit checks:
- **Hard inquiries** (when a lender checks your credit because you apply for credit) – *can* lower your score a bit
- **Soft inquiries** (when you check your own score or a lender does a pre-approval) – **do not affect your score**
When you:
- Check your score on a bank app
- Use credit monitoring services
- Pull your own report from AnnualCreditReport.com
…those are soft inquiries. They **won’t hurt your score**.
Action Step
- Get comfortable checking your own credit **monthly** or **quarterly**. Treat it like checking your weight or blood pressure: just data, no shame.
---
Myth #2: “You Have to Carry a Balance to Build Credit”
You might have heard: “Leave a little on your card each month—that builds credit.”
The Truth
You build credit by **using credit and paying on time**, not by paying interest.
If your statement balance is $300 and you pay the full $300 by the due date:
- You still show **on-time payment history**
- The card still reports **usage** and **repayment**
- You avoid paying any interest
Carrying a balance from month to month only
- Costs you **extra interest**
- Can **increase your utilization** (which may lower your score)
Action Step
- Use your card for small, planned purchases (like gas or a streaming service)
- Pay the **full statement balance** each month if you can
You’ll still build credit—without unnecessary interest.
---
Myth #3: “Closing Old Credit Cards Will Boost Your Score”
Many people close old cards to feel more “responsible” or simplified.
The Truth
Closing a credit card can actually **hurt** your score in two ways:
1. It can reduce your **total available credit**, increasing your utilization.
2. It can reduce your **average age of accounts**, which is a factor in your score.
Example:
Before closing:
- Card A limit: $1,000, balance: $200
- Card B limit: $2,000, balance: $300
- Total limit: $3,000; total balance: $500 → Utilization ≈ **16.7%**
You close Card B (limit $2,000):
- Total limit: now $1,000; total balance: still $500 → Utilization = **50%**
Your utilization jumps from 16.7% to 50% without adding any new debt.
Action Step
- If an old card has **no annual fee**, consider keeping it open, using it occasionally, and paying it off monthly.
- If a card has a high annual fee and you don’t use it, you may decide to close it—but be aware of the potential short-term score impact.
---
Myth #4: “All Debt Is Bad for Your Credit”
You might think having **any** loans is automatically bad.
The Truth
Credit scores are about **how you manage debt**, not whether you have zero debt.
In fact, having **no credit accounts at all** can make it:
- Harder to get a score in the first place
- Harder for lenders to judge your risk
Healthy use of credit can **help** you:
- An affordable car loan, paid on time, builds a strong record
- A credit card used lightly and paid in full shows responsibility
The problem is **unmanageable debt**, not all debt.
Action Step
- Focus on borrowing only what you can realistically **afford to repay**
- Use credit tools (like cards or small loans) intentionally, not impulsively
---
Myth #5: “Paying Off a Collection Will Remove It from Your Credit Report”
Many people are shocked when they pay off a collection and it still appears.
The Truth
Paying off a collection usually updates the status to **“paid”** or **“paid, settled”**, but:
- The account itself often stays on your report for up to **7 years** from the original delinquency date
However, paying a collection can still **help** you:
- Some credit scoring models **ignore paid collections** entirely
- Lenders often look more favorably at **paid** vs. unpaid collections
Action Step
- When paying a collection, ask the collector what they will report (in writing if possible)
- Don’t expect instant removal, but do know that **paid** is better than **unpaid** for future lending decisions
---
Myth #6: “Your Income Directly Determines Your Credit Score”
People often assume a higher salary = higher credit score.
The Truth
Your **income is not part of your credit score formula**.
Your score looks at:
- Payment history
- Utilization
- Length of history
- New credit inquiries
- Credit mix
Income *matters* to lenders when they decide **how much** to lend you, but it doesn’t directly change your score.
That said, income can **indirectly** affect your score because:
- Higher income may make it easier to pay on time and keep balances low
- Lower income may make it harder to keep up with payments
Action Step
- Focus on behaviors you control (payments, balances, applications), regardless of income
- If your income rises, consider using that as an opportunity to **pay down debt** and strengthen your profile
---
Myth #7: “Once Your Credit Is Bad, It’s Ruined Forever”
This is one of the most discouraging myths—and it’s simply not true.
The Truth
Credit scores are designed to **change** over time.
Negative items do stay for years, but:
- Their **impact fades** as they get older
- New **positive history** can eventually outweigh old mistakes
Example timeline for someone starting at a **560** score:
- **Months 1–3:** All payments on time, utilization drops under 50% → score may move into **high 500s/low 600s**
- **Months 4–9:** Some collections paid, utilization below 30% → score may move into **mid–600s**
- **Months 10–18:** Strong payment history, aging negatives → many people see scores in **high 600s or low 700s**
Everyone’s journey is different, but improvement is **absolutely possible**.
Action Step
- Treat your current score as **starting data**, not a life sentence
- Pick **one or two habits** to focus on this month (e.g., on-time payments + lowering one balance)
---
Turning Knowledge into Action
Knowing the truth behind these myths gives you power.
To recap, remember:
1. **Checking your own score is safe** – it’s a soft inquiry
2. You **don’t need to carry a balance** to build credit
3. Closing cards can hurt by shrinking your available credit and account age
4. Not all debt is bad—**unmanaged** debt is the issue
5. Paying a collection won’t always remove it, but it still helps
6. Your **income doesn’t set your score**, your habits do
7. Bad credit today does **not** mean bad credit forever
Pick one myth you believed and take a small action today to move in the right direction. Your credit story is still being written—and you’re the author.